Thursday, July 10, 2014

Texas Courthouse Trail article for The Retired Badge, August 2014

Caldwell County Courthouse, Lockhart, Texas

Texas Courthouse Trails

After I retired from HPD Homicide in 2005, if you had told me that I would someday embark on a program to visit and photograph every one of the 254 Texas courthouses of Texas, I would have said,” You’re crazy.”  Nevertheless, for the last four years I have been doing just that, driving with my photography buddy Dave, to 187 (so far) different county seats, photographing each one, inside and out, and gathering information unique to each county and its courthouse. 

Having worked murder cases for 29 years in the Homicide Division, I have spent a lot of time in courthouses, usually waiting to testify.  Logically, that would be the last place thing I wanted to see again.  All that changed in 2010 when I made a trip to Anderson, Texas, county seat of Grimes County and took a good look at their impressive courthouse situated on a hill.
 
Grimes County Courthouse
The Grimes County courthouse was built in 1893 and is located in the middle of the town of Anderson. The structure dominates all the other surrounding buildings. The two-story structure is built of stone and brick in the “Italianate style”. The stairwell to the second floor courtroom is on the exterior south side of the structure.  The brick is a tan color and the building is trimmed in white. 

With a grant from the Courthouse Preservation Program that was initiated by then Governor George W. Bush, the courthouse was restored to its original 1893 look by the citizens of Grimes County. It is one of sixty historic courthouses that have been restored by the Bush program. Yep! Bush did it!

When you read about the names of each county and county seat, it’s like reading all about Texas history.  For example, Anderson was named for Kenneth Lewis Anderson, Vice-President of the Republic of Texas. Another example would be Grimes County, named for Jesse Grimes, a signer of the Texas Declaration of Independence. 
 
Fayette County Courthouse
The next county courthouse I visited was the Fayette County courthouse in La Grange.  Built in 1891 and designed by famed architect, J. Riely Gordon, it is one of the most beautiful buildings in Texas.  It is built of rough and dressed stone in what is known as the Richardsonian Romanesque style. This courthouse has three stories. As with most Texas courthouses, the courtroom is on the second floor and a courtroom balcony on the third.

The original structure had an open atrium with a large fountain, cast iron sculptures and tropical plants.  Later the atrium was closed off for vaults and additional office space. Subsequently, it was restored, along with other interior features, to the original condition under the THC program and rededicated in 2005.  It was reopened with fountain, sculptures and tropical plants creating a uniquely beautiful feature to the 123 year-old building. 

As I drove home from La Grange it occurred to me that I only had 252 counties to go.  I thought to myself:  “Well, might as well do it.”  All I’m going to miss is “Jeopardy” in the afternoon.  I was hooked and thus began my journeys across, up, down and all over Texas.

I am not the first, nor will I be the last to visit and photograph all the Texas county courthouses.  Mavis P. Kelsey Sr. (founder of Kelsey-Seybold Clinic) and Donald H. Dyal did the same thing and published The Courthouses of Texas in 1993.  Others have also made the trips but this book was the first comprehensive guide.   It has served me well for the past four years and offers photos of each courthouse along with a short history of each one.

Here are some historical facts that I learned:

1.    When Texas became a firmly established republic in 1837, there were 37 municipal districts with the larger districts divided into counties.  Bexar County, known as the “Mother of Counties” extended west to El Paso, south to the Rio Grande and north to the top of the Panhandle.  There were four courthouses built during the times of the Republic of Texas: Colorado, Brazoria, Harris, and Harrison.  None of these buildings survived.

2.    How was the size of counties determined?  It was usually determined by the distance citizens could travel to reach the county seat and get back in a day by horseback or horse-drawn vehicle.  A thirty mile round trip was a long day’s ride for outlying farmers and ranchers and thus most counties are thirty miles in diameter.
  
3. The Texas Constitution mandated that each county seat was to be established in the geographical center (plus or minus three miles) of the county.  There are exceptions to this rule but for the most part county seats are located in the middle of the county. 

4.   I’ve discovered this interesting fact in my own travels across Texas.  From any one courthouse, I can count on the next county being about 35 miles away.  Also, Texas road signs indicating miles to the next county seat are not the miles to the city limits, but rather miles to the courthouse square.

One of the things I love about Texas is those courthouse squares, found in most county seat towns, excluding the large cities. They are Texas icons. The practice of laying out a town with a central plaza for government buildings and streets came from the Spanish, who had gotten the idea from the Romans.  Additionally, early Texas Republic immigrants brought with them the concept of the courthouse square as found in colonial America. 

As the Comanche were pushed out of the lands in central and west Texas, folks began to immigrate westward into Texas.  As towns grew in size and in population, the different counties were drawn up by the Texas legislature.  A priority for these new towns was their designation as a county seat and where to put the courthouse.

The history of the jostling, the fights and crimes committed to secure a town as a county seat offers an insight into how important it was to have these courthouses. Here are a couple of examples from the Handbook of Texas Online. 

"The town of Montgomery, situated on the stagecoach line that ran from Huntsville to Houston, was made the first county seat ..."
"The construction of ... railroads [in the county] touched off an intense controversy concerning the location of the county seat.”

When the first railroad missed the town of Montgomery, a new town on the railroad called Willis, was voted in as county seat in 1874. Six years later the county seat was moved back to Montgomery when the Houston and Texas Central railroads were completed. In 1889, however, the county seat was moved to the fledgling community of Conroe because it was situated at the junction of [the two railroads]." Handbook of Texas Online. Conclusion: The railroads were an important factor in the layout of Texas counties and county seats.
 
Blanco County Courthouse, Johnson City, Texas
In 1862, during the Civil War, the legislature established Kendall County and because of that, Blanco County lost a large part of the land on its southwestern border. The legislature compensated Blanco County by giving it additional parts of Hays and Burnet counties. When all the changes were complete, Blanco County comprised the 714 square miles of land that it occupies to this day.  However, the town of Blanco was no longer at its geographical center.  Therefore, the residents of Johnson City and the new northern part of the county called for an election to relocate the county seat to Johnson City.  The people of Blanco mocked them but when the votes were counted Johnson City won by seven votes. It was rumored that some horses and dogs voted in that election. 

A second election was called for and it was held in 1886 and Blanco won its county seat back. The issue polarized the citizens to the point that men were ready to fight with fists and guns over of the courthouse location.  A third and final election in 1891 settled the issue and Johnson City won the county seat fight and within hours all the county records were loaded into wagons and moved to Johnson CityHill County: Lone Star Guides by Richard Zelade and Handbook of Texas Online.
 
Old Blanco County Courthouse, Blanco, Texas
The old courthouse in Blanco still stands today.  It has been restored and appears at it did in the 1880s.  Today it serves as a tourist information center for visitors to the Texas Hill Country.

The first Texas courthouses were log structures.  The original Comanche County courthouse was in the town of Cora was built in 1856.  It was preserved, dismantled and moved to Comanche on the courthouse square. 
 
Cass County Courthouse, Linden, Texas
The oldest, longest serving courthouse in Texas can be found in Linden, Cass County.  The Classical Revival style courthouse was built in 1861 of brick.  It is the only surviving antebellum courthouse in Texas.

After the Civil War and post-reconstruction, (between 1870 and 1900) the State of Texas entered a period of prosperity that was buoyed by a national demand for cotton and beef.  With tax revenue generated by that prosperity, Texas counties began to build the many courthouses that still stand today.  
This period is often referred to as the “Golden Age of Texas Courthouses.”  Architects would compete with each other hoping to land lucrative contracts with each county.  Some of the great Texas architects include: J. Riely Gordon, Atlee B. Ayers, W. C. Dodson, Eugene T. Heiner, Alfred Giles and the Ruffini brothers.  Their designs include; Classical Revival, Romanesque Revival, French Second Empire (see first photo of Caldwell County courthouse), Renaissance Revival and Beau Arts. 

Later on, other architects would adopt a combination of three or more of these classic architecture styles and produce a style that became known as Texas Renaissance. These buildings often required skilled European masons, artists, carpenters along with local construction workers.

The last two architectural styles are Moderne and Modern.  The Moderne with the extra “e” designates a style that is found in buildings constructed in the 1930’s and 1940’s. These courthouses often have Art Deco ornaments and decorations.  You can see them carved into the stonework or in metal eagles, shields and scales of justice on the exterior of the building.  The Washington County courthouse in Brenham is an excellent example of this Moderne style of architecture.

The Modern style of courthouses is what is being built today.  Gone are the skilled European stone masons, artists, and carpenters.  They have been replaced by concrete, steel and glass and the crane. Still these courthouses, such as the Harris County Criminal or Civil Courts buildings are not only pleasing to the eye, but they are large enough to function as a courthouse for the larger counties in Texas.

I should mention the El Paso County courthouse because of something interesting that happened to me during my visit there.  My wife and I made an 1800 mile, four-day trip to West Texas, visiting and photographing county courthouses as we drove from county seat to county seat.  We arrived in El Paso mid-morning and parked in a lot about two blocks across the street from the federal courthouse.  My wife stayed with the car because we had our dog along, and I hiked to the courthouse. Stand by for what happened!


The El Paso County courthouse is a stunning building in the Modern style architectural building with a lot of mirrored glass and red brick.  Its most unique feature is found on the third floor where you will find a mural by celebrated artist Carlos Callejo. It is titled, "Our History" (1995) and it spans three walls beneath the glass ceiling of this modern building.

Visitors entering the courthouse have to be screened by deputies and pass through a metal detector.  I did this and I asked one of the deputies where I could photograph the mural. He said take the elevator to the third floor for a good view. I followed his suggestion and got some great photos.

Now here’s what happened to me! Upon exiting the building I walked back to the car and started putting my camera in its case. Suddenly I was confronted by an FBI agent and two deputy US Marshalls who started bombarding me with questions about why I was photographing the courthouse.  For a moment I thought I was about to be arrested.

The first thing I did was ask them for some credentials.  The FBI agent showed me his.  When I in turn slowly pulled my HPD ID, they suddenly got apologetic.  I explained that I was photographing all the Texas county courthouses for a book.  They still wanted to see the photographs on my camera which I showed them. 

The FBI agent said that they get threats from the Mexican drug cartels and they wanted to make sure I was not doing a recon mission.  I asked the agent, “Do you think an old guy like me, wearing a Texas A&M t-shirt and US Air Force ball cap is working for the cartel?”  I think if I had not had my HPD ID things could have gone quite differently.

A serendipity of these trips has been the great people I have met in and around the courthouse.  I was given a personal tour of the Bell County courthouse and his office by District Judge Jack Jones who found it interesting that I was photographing his courtroom.  He talked about the fire that destroyed the courthouse in 1993 and how the county rebuilt the courthouse.  I met Sheriff Hilario Canto, at the Kimble County courthouse in Sonora, Texas.  He invited me into his office for coffee.  He was elected three years ago and prior to that served as a deputy. 

In Eldorado, Texas I met county judge, Charlie Bradley.  He noticed my Nikon and asked me about my project and then offered to help stage the courtroom lighting for the photos.  Judge Bradley is a graduate of Texas Tech University with a degree in photojournalism.  He moved back to Eldorado to take care of his parents and opened a portrait photography business.

In my travels, I have met county treasurers, county clerks, deputy sheriffs and even people looking for where to buy a marriage license.  One thing they all have in common is they are very Texas proud of their courthouse.
 
Shelby County Courthouse, Center, Texas
I made a trip through East Texas to the town of Center, county seat of Shelby County.  The Shelby County courthouse was built in 1885 and is the only courthouse in the United States that resembles an Irish castle.  It was designed and built by J. J. Emmitt Gibson using two million bricks. It no longer serves as a functioning courthouse but serves as a historical museum. 

I was given a personal tour by the caretaker, Mr. Jones. We began the tour on the first floor hallway with him pointing out an 1885 silver dollar embedded into the wooden floor where two hallways intersected.  He pointed to the coin saying: “That is the exact geographical center of Shelby County.”  He then showed me a narrow door that concealed a spiral staircase that allows judges to enter the courtroom.  Later on the second floor he showed me the door where they would emerge from behind the bench.  The second floor windows in the courtroom were designed to be opened from the top and bottom allowing hot air to escape and cooler air, if any available, to enter the courtroom.
Shelby County Courthouse:  Courtroom

The problem with large open windows was it also allowed birds to fly into the courtroom.  During a murder trial in the 1890’s the trial judge noticed some jurors looking at the pigeon on the rafter instead of listening to the witness.  He stopped the trial and cleared the courtroom.  He told the bailiff to use any means necessary to remove the bird, as it was in contempt of the court.  A shotgun quickly removed the contemptuous pigeon and the trial continued without any further distraction.


In many Texas towns, the courthouse square is the resting place for some very unique historical items.  For example, the Bee County courthouse square has a US Navy jet on the grounds.  It is not, however, combat ready.  Down the road at the Live Oak County courthouse square you will find “Geronimo,” a stuffed Texas longhorn commemorating where longhorns and trail drives originated. 

The Bandera County square has a rock memorial with a bronze plaque honoring all cowboys.  Mason County has a cowboy with his horse in the front of the courthouse.  The Goliad County courthouse still has an original “hanging tree” in front.  In Fairfield, Texas at the county seat of Freestone County you’ll find one of three canons from the Civil War Battle of Val Verde.

The McCullough County courthouse square in Brady has a huge granite statue of Texas with a big red heart in the middle which proudly states it is the “heart of Texas.” In Seguin on the Guadalupe County courthouse grounds, Juan Seguin is mounted on his horse, sword drawn and all in bronze.  It reminds us of that the Tejanos also fought for Texas independence at the Battle of San Jacinto.

When the War Between the States broke out in 1861, Texas joined the Confederacy, much to the dismay of famous Texans like Sam Houston.  By the end of 1861, 25,000 Texans were in the Confederate army, the majority in the cavalry. 
 
Denton County Confederate Soldiers Memorial
The Civil War resulted in the deaths of over 600,000 soldiers, both North and South. Many of the volunteers from Texas were killed or wounded.  Almost every Texas County that existed prior to 1860 has a Confederate memorial on its courthouse square.  These memorials were erected by the Daughters of the Confederacy.  Several civil rights groups have attempted to have them removed, all unsuccessfully.

The most common thing found on nearly every one of the 254 county courthouse squares is a Veterans’ memorial.  Some are small while others are massive.  The largest one I’ve ever seen is next to the Hopkins County courthouse in Sulphur Springs.  It is the largest feature of the courthouse square other than the courthouse itself. 
 
Nacogdoches County Veterans Memorial
Another notable Veterans’ memorial is found in Nacogdoches County courthouse square.  It has the names of every county resident who has ever served in the Armed Forces of the United States listing their service, rank, where they served and dates of service.  In addition a granite monolith is dedicated to Purple Heart recipients. 

The Hunt County courthouse square in Greenville has a bust and memorial of America’s most decorated soldier, Audie Murphy.  The citizens of Starr County erected a memorial to Gregoiro Barrera, WW2 Veteran, POW, and survivor of the Bataan Death March and they named the plaza in his honor.  Veterans are truly honored by every Texas County.

I often get asked about the most awesome, beautiful courthouse I have visited and photographed. To be fair I have to tell you about three!
 
Harris County Courthouse of 1910
I’ll start with my third choice, the Harris County Courthouse of 1910.  You may know it as the old Civil Courts building.  It was designed by architect Charles E. Barglebaugh of Lang & Mitchell, in Beaux-Arts style architecture.  The main entrance is on Fannin Street.  It has eight giant granite columns.  There are elaborate ornamentation in limestone and masonry.  The exterior is built from Texas pink granite and light brown St. Louis brick.  The interior walls and floor are finished in gray and white Cherokee marble that is eye-popping elegant.  If you ever go there, be sure to walk directly under the dome on the first floor and look up into a stained glass kaleidoscope lit by windows around the dome. It is amazing. 
Harris County Courthouse of 1910

 The five year restoration began in 2006 and it was completed and rededicated in 2011 at a cost of $65 million. The original courthouse cost was $500,000 in 1910.
 
My second choice is the Ellis County courthouse in Waxahachie designed by famed architect, J. Riely Gordon.  This is a massive red sandstone and granite Romanesque Revival courthouse.  The three-story building is topped by a two-story granite clock tower that appears to be another building on top of the courthouse.  The courthouse can be seen from miles away from town. The center of the building is open from the first floor to the top of the clock tower creating a chimney effect and cooling the building.  Renovations and restoration provide air conditioning and all the comforts of modern life.

The Ellis County courthouse cost an estimated $75,000 in 1896. Still the area cotton farmers at the time thought that was too extravagant and they voted all of the county commissioners out of office.  As the courthouse was being built and the people saw the building as it was being finished they changed their minds and voted all the rebuked commissioners back into office. 

Ellis County Courthouse
The courthouse has elaborate stone faces on the ground floor carved by master stone masons.  The faces on the east side appear to be happy while growing melancholy on the west side.  One explanation for that is the stone mason was seeing a certain young woman at the start of the project, however, she rejected him later and his feelings were reflected in his stone carvings.

Harrison County Courthouse, Marshall, Texas

My all time favorite courthouse is found in Marshall, Texas, county seat Harrison County.  This is another J. Riely Gordon design built in 1900 in the Renaissance Revival style.  It has everything you could imagine in a classic courthouse including a domed roof and clock tower with a statue of Lady Justice on the top, carved eagles over the cornices and ten eagles around the dome.

This courthouse was built from yellow brick with gray Corinthian granite columns on three sides and the entire building is trimmed in white limestone.  It sits on a slight hill and is surrounded by red brick parking lot and street.  A statue of a Confederate soldier oversees the east entrance.  The interior has been restored to its original condition.  Looking up into the dome from the first floor rotunda, you can see the stained glass that provides light into the top.  It is an impressive courthouse and worth a stop in Marshall.  Just beware that there are red light cameras everywhere in this East Texas town, not that I’m speaking from experience of course!


I have been all over this state and stopped in towns I never knew existed: Big Lake, Crane, Eldorado, Sarita, Tilden, Hamilton, Center, and Sterling City just to name a few.  They all have a courthouse, some better than others. They all have something else in common. They all have Texans, the friendliest people on earth. I’ll be going to Panhandle soon, but not just to finish this project.  I look forward to see whom I’m going to meet and to hear about their life stories.

You can see 187 county courthouses at my website:


My email address is there also, drop me a line. waynewendel@yahoo.com

  

No comments:

Post a Comment